Post by JonbhoyAge shouldnt play a factor?So in that case we stick with him until he is
60 then?Sorry but age does play a factor in terms of speed etc,its a
scientific fact.Some do play on indeed but thats not what we should be
doing,look where its getting us with that mentality.Id rather play someone
younger that a scout pointed out than Weir,thats nothing against his age
or skill.
Yes age plays a factor in speed etc, but you do not automatically dump
someone when he is 30, 35, or 40 just because they've reached a certain age.
You ask if they still have it. Davie Weir still has it. To dump him because
of his age is ageist lol! If you think Diamond, Berra etc are better players
then fine, but not because they are younger. Sure try out younger players in
friendlies, but when it's competitive, you select the best players.
Post by JonbhoyPost by StevioIf a 39 year old Maldini was Scottish, would you have rather had him in
at centre-half against the Dutch the other night, or would you have
preferred Steven Caldwell, Berra, Diamond or Anderson?
Would maldini have played that header?If so yes id have chosen any of the
others! ;-)
Caldwell, McManus etc make mistakes. If you played any of the others I've
listed they would make mistakes too. Caldwell has made a number of mistakes
recently. If he was in his 30s people would say it's his age. It's not, he
just made mistakes.
Look at the goal again from Wednesday, who else was to blame? Hutton! One of
the youngest, fastest guys in our team. Why? Because he wasn't switched on
mentally. He should have realised Weir was struggling to get to that header
and covered, just like Weir does for other players.
Post by JonbhoyI was semi pro to a pretty good level but never good enough to be a pro
then had health problems late 20's onwards which cut sport short so cant
really say.As you said Weir had no pace before so whats he got now?Weir is
not the future and should stick to playing club level.
But up until Wednesday he was still the present.
Post by JonbhoyWhich we lost....due to a Weir mistake!But being fair i am by no means
blaming Weir for our failing to get to the WC,that goes way past the
Holland game.
Also due to Hutton at the goal, Miller for his mistake, etc. It's a team
game.
Post by JonbhoyBerti was a who never believed he made a mistake and should never have
been allowed to manage Scotland, and as you say Brown did stick with the
same players but the players seemed to have more faith in themselves (Much
like when WS was in charge).But this is what i am saying that now we have
only friendlies i would go full steam into picking out the best few then
pack it out with as many new faces as we can (The scouts and clubs need to
help out more with this).the scores,lets have say 4 games trying out new
faces maybe from the U21's cause we must have our own Theo Walcott out
there somewhere!
This sounds very much like Berti's approach! We don't have a Walcott,
players that good are rare. We do have Fleck who might be the best teenager
coming through we know of, but he's not ready yet. We don't need to start
from scratch.
We have the basis of a good squad. We need to build on it and bring players
in gradually. Guys like Whittaker, Naismith, McCormack have all impressed in
recent games. Add to that McFadden, Brown, Fletcher, Fletcher, Gordon, Kevin
Thomson as well, and you have the basis of a good (and young) team. There
are plenty of centre halves about, the 2 at Celtic, Berra, Diamond,
Anderson, Wilkie, Webster etc, but they have to step up to the plate and
show they are good enough, otherwise we'll still need to call on the likes
of Weir if the others aren't good enough.
What do people think of Maloney? He's one who I don't think really does it
for Scotland, that I've noticed. Thoughts?